#34
Tier 3 — Caution Advised

Gerolsteiner

3.6/10

Expert Summary

Heavy German sparkling mineral water with ultra-high mineral content that tastes overly metallic to the average consumer.

How This Score Was Calculated

The PHI Score for Gerolsteiner (3.6/10) is a composite of four independently weighted pillars evaluated through third-party lab testing, corporate disclosure analysis, and environmental lifecycle assessments.

30%

Recovery & Performance

25%

Eco-Packaging

25%

Microplastic Testing

20%

Corporate Ethics

Read full methodology

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Gerolsteiner a good bottled water?

Gerolsteiner is ranked #34 of 50 with a score of 3.6/10. Exercise caution — Heavy German sparkling mineral water with ultra-high mineral content that tastes overly metallic to the average consumer.

How was Gerolsteiner ranked on BestBottledWater.org?

Gerolsteiner received a PHI Score of 3.6/10 across four weighted criteria: Recovery & Performance Testing (30%), Eco-Packaging Metrics (25%), Microplastic Testing (25%), and Corporate Ethics Audit (20%). This placed it at rank #34 out of 50 brands evaluated in the 2026 annual index.

Similar Brands in Tier 3 — Caution Advised